WHY IT’S IMPORTANT TO THINK ABOUT PRIVILEGE – AND WHY IT’S HARD

I am a social worker. By virtue of the work I do, I think a lot about privilege. The process of becoming comfortable and open to acknowledging, critiquing, and accepting my own privilege hasn’t been easy. It didn’t happen all at once. I have had many aha movements that have helped me to understand my own privilege in relation to the clients I am serving and the world at large.

My profession puts me in the position of assisting individuals who are in need of resources, and who are often facing economic, educational, and environmental conditions different than my own. Further, when assigned a new case, I immediately hold a degree of authority over the client. Social workers are gatekeepers to resources that an individual needs  – and are often unable to access without assistance. It’s a complicated dynamic. Good social workers attempt to curb the power imbalance, but it’s critical we acknowledge a simple truth: as professional social service workers we are, by-and-large, working from positions of privilege over our clients.

Photo: poncho.com one of my many “aha” moments

Thinking about privilege and challenging it is an ongoing exercise. It’s something that has become part of my daily consciousness. But it’s a difficult concept to grapple with – and one that I didn’t come easily. I am constantly learning to challenge my position in the world, and understand the power imbalances that I am a part of. With friends, I sometimes will bring up the subject of privilege (not in a preachy way, I swear!) and am always surprised at how divisive the topic is.

Case in point: At a dinner with a friend to who works on Wall Street, I began discussing a recent New York Times article that looked at how high school students challenged and thought about privilege. I said, “I find it sad that a student was quoted as saying that she didn’t want to be called privileged, just because her parents were able to buy things.” There was a long pause, and my dining companion responded, “Well, who is to say she is privileged? She could be experiencing a lot of things that make her life hard.”

Photo: Pearly

This comment is the crux of the issue when discussing privilege and how many misunderstand the term. Having privilege does not mean that an individual is immune to life’s hardships, but it does mean having an unearned benefit or advantage one receives in society by nature of their identity. Examples of types of identity that can afford an individual privilege include: race, gender, sexual orientation, religion, socioeconomic status, country of origin, lanuage, and/or ability.

I’ll use myself as an example: my privilege stems from my whiteness, cisgenderedness, middle-class upbringing, education, resources to food, access to health care, and familial support. In many ways, I am an expert on the ways my privilege has benefitted me. This is not to ignore that my gender, femininity, and introversion don’t at times put me at a disadvantage, but it doesn’t take away from the many unearned benefits I was handed simply from being born with certain traits and resources.

When I explained this to my friend during our fancy West Village meal, he became defensive. He cited his struggles learning to read, being born into a household with parents who had immigrated from Europe, and being in debt from school as reasons that he should not be assumed to be privileged. While he did reference the disadvantages that women and minorities experience, he would not identify with the label of privilege.

In my experience, his level of defensiveness is not unusual when discussing privilege. When I think about unacknowledged privilege as a phenomenon, I recognize that since hierarchies in most societies are interlocking, there is most likely a lot of privilege (be it gendered, white, heteronormative, socioeconomic) that is denied and protected. As a white person, I realize that I have been taught about privilege as something that puts others at a disadvantage, but I haven’t been taught to see one of its corally aspects – that my privilege puts me at an advantage over others. What I am reflecting in this article is not my inherent understanding of privilege, but rather a reflection on the knowledge I have gained through friends, mentors, teachers, observation, and reading.

As society generally does not give lessons on how to combat and speak about privilege, it puts the onus on us, global citizens, to address imbalances. While privilege is a tricky subject to talk about, and can spark misunderstanding. From my work as a social worker, I suggest a list of five tactics I use when discussing privilege with others – or with yourself.

1. Lead with empathy. Get an understanding of individual experience.

Photo: pocho.com

I find that part of the issue in discussing privilege, is that even individuals who have LOTS of privilege want to be acknowledged for their hardships. This makes sense – we all want empathy towards our life challenges.

When I first enter into a conversation about privilege, I start by asking about the ways in which the person does not have privilege. This is helpful not only in understanding the person more, but also extending empathy. In a conversation as touchy as one on privilege, it’s important to try to disarm defensives and cultivate open dialogue. Then, after speaking with the person about the ways in which they don’t hold privilege, I ask in what ways they do. (I’ll use myself as an example: while I am a woman, dyslexic, and have a chronic medical condition, I ALSO have the privilege of being upper-middle class, living in the United States, holding a graduate degree, having financial resources, and being white.)

I find that structuring a conversation that includes the way people have and don’t have privileges makes it easier for others to understand the power of privilege in creating a system of oppression – and this process is transformative.

2. Understanding the relativity of privilege

Photo: nachoganyreserve.com

 

For instance, I am right handed, and in turn, have never been forced to write from a desk that is not fitted for me. It’s a privilege I have by nature of my birth. But it’s not to say that my right-handed privilege has the same social responsibility as the privilege that is my white skin color, wealth, and sexual orientation. The point I am trying to make is this: our identities are nuanced and intersectional.

Some of my close friends will get defensive when discussing privilege because they are afraid that the discussion will not talk about the powerful ways in which they do not have privilege, and as a defense, they deflect to speaking to only these things.

It’s important to understand – just because we have don’t have certain kinds of privileges, it doesn’t mean that we don’t benefit from other kinds of privileges. If we realize this, it’s easier to work together with folks who share our privileges and those who don’t to create a better, more equal, world.

3. Systematic injustice is good for no one

Photo: thedailyblog.co.nz

Systemic privilege hurts everyone.

Consider white privilege – For instance, in the US white privilege is a construction created by rich Europeans who wanted to combine their wealth by pitting poor Europeans against Indigenous and African peoples working as slaves. Poor white people were made to feel that they were superior to other races, and were given small privileges over people of color to create diversion. What this meant was that poor white individuals got to be superior to blacks, but still were not on equal footing with wealthy whites. Ultimately, these privileges don’t create advantage for the vast majority of the population, and subsequently, this division creates unfairness – and that’s bad.

Similarly, men have social and economic privileges over women. This is created from a deep rooted patriarchy that prioritizes men over women. Male privilege isn’t helping anyone ultimately though – it doesn’t help families where mothers make less than male partners, and it doesn’t benefit women in helping to advance the fields of science, math, technology, journalism, finance, and engineering. We all lose when people are treated unfairly and not on the merit of their person.

Ultimately, in order to move from a space of marginalization, people need to confront their privileges and recognize that  inequality helps no one. As global citizens, we  have the revolutionary ability to transform the political, economic, and social environment by recognizing that injustice creates a societal imbalance that negatively impacts everyone.

4. You don’t need to feel guilty or defensive when discussing privilege

Photo: thefec.org

One of the best life-lessons my father taught me was that guilt is a useless emotion. And it’s true. Guilt is a feeling that ultimately does nothing in bringing about change. I try to use this concept when I talk to friends about privilege. A lot of time, people will respond with defensives, or guilt. I have had my fair share of conversations where someone will literally (and I mean literally) throw up their arms and say, “It’s unfair, sure! But what am I going to do?”

To this I respond with a reminder that each of us is able to undermine the system of oppression by refusing to live with unchecked or unacknowledged privilege. Simply by reflecting and challenging our privileges, and working to change the system of discrimination through direct discussion, we can help to shift the status quo.

5. Consider ways in which to equalize power

Photo: wehearit.com | some people carry “lesser” burdens

To create change, it’s important to frame discussion on privilege with actions. As such, the conversation shouldn’t be, “Check your privilege, stupid!” but rather, “How can we work to make sure that we are understanding and undermining the system of oppression and privilege that hurts all of us?”

By framing the dialogue on action, and steps toward liberation, the conversation is more accessible and powerful. For instance, ask yourself questions like, “Can I, if I wish, arrange to be in the company of people of my race most of the time?” If the answer to this question is yes, challenge yourself to address why this is. Is it strictly due to demographics, or are those demographics shaped by historical discrimination? (For a list of anti-oppression questions, visit Dr. Peggy McIntosh’s open letter here).

For more actionable change, reach out to like-minded people within your community. I will give a personal example on how addressing my privilege got me involved in grassroots organizing: After a year of working as a social worker, I was dismayed by inequalities within social services. I reached out to a group that mobilized social service workers who were committed to addressing injustice. By joining with others with similar interests, I felt I was working to transform a broken welfare system, and it resulted in my professional work being more impactful.

I encourage all global citizens to reflect on the privileges you have, and the privileges you don’t have. Extend this conversation to your friends and family members to build a world that is focused on equality and fairness.


In order to break the systems of oppression within our societies, it is important to intentionally set-aside time to think about justice, and whether or not our values are aligning with the ways in which we live our lives.

What are your thoughts on privilege? Is it a topic you have familiarity with? Share your thoughts in the comments, and continue the discussion about privilege with friends and family members!

—-

Kathleen Ebbitt

Source: http://www.globalcitizen.org/Content/Content.aspx?id=5cec8f58-47e0-4a74-9a8b-fe79bdd9f680

3 Responses to WHY IT’S IMPORTANT TO THINK ABOUT PRIVILEGE – AND WHY IT’S HARD

  1. Dennis Kenyon says:

    In women’s and African-American studies programs, and in much mainstream media reporting as well, the content of Peggy McIntosh’s 1988 working paper is now taken as social fact for the USA, although its title states that it is her own personal reflection. “For me, white privilege has turned out to be an elusive and fugitive subject,” she says. Indeed. The business of ascribing individual human experience and behavior to memberships in the identity groups we have defined carries risk of committing the fallacies of composition and of division: Institutionalized racism does not inherit separate intelligence and purpose from its practitioners. And if privileges do accrue to one of the groups, it does not follow that they will accrue to each member of that group.

    There is good reason to believe that discriminatory practices remain common, for instance as shown by “resume stings” where the candidate’s name is the test variable in an experiment with blind job applications. But I think the character of discrimination has changed even since McIntosh wrote. People invoke more criteria on which to discriminate than was formerly the case, calling into question the simple bright lines of race, ethnicity, and gender we continue to use as proxies for life chances estimates. If not individual “merit,” individual circumstance and strategy certainly matter more today. Since 1970, between-groups variations on such measures of welfare as income, educational attainment, and life expectancy have narrowed somewhat, while within-group variations on these measures have greatly increased. Race and gender are gradually losing their predictive power. It is no longer a safe bet that a black person in the USA will be poor.

    I can remember when that last statement wasn’t true. When I look at the first of Pearly’s cartoons above, I don’t see the white lady as deliberately blind to the significance of either race or of group privilege. I see her reacting against the idea that she therefore owes concessions. Entitlement sense, like other products of the ego, will be protected by denial mechanisms. These, however, are rhetorical tools for dealing with perceived external threats—the lady is well aware that loss of her group’s status could have personal consequences for her, but equally aware that she can’t do much about it. The aggregate situations of our groups are always beyond our control. In other words, her perspective is self-centered rather than attached to any ideology governing race relations. What she needs is assurance that making those concessions will not adversely affect her own position.

    And I’m not sure she’s getting it from the multicultural camp, or that reflections of the kind McIntosh suggests will provide it for her. Relations between identity groups by nature involve conflict. This is why they are settled (ideally) by negotiation and not by emotion work.

  2. Rhonda says:

    Are you hiring? I wanna get paid to whine about white people too!

  3. Shekel Goldberg says:

    I am privileged because I have the right to choose how I want to live my life.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

F0212 u

Please type the text above:

Read reports by date

July 2017
M T W T F S S
« Jun    
 12
3456789
10111213141516
17181920212223
24252627282930
31  

Most Recent Reports

Mariaha McCluskey

i am glad to report my ex girlfriend (Mariaha Derian McCluskey)living in Canton Ohio ,

He didn\'t sell me car because I\'m Turkish

I was searching a car to buy on Craigslist.com and I liked one car it

Was threatened and called Nigger by a passing car of 4 white racist guys

Have photo and plate of the guys who repeatedly said Nigger and them follow ed

Studio 23 just dislike white people.

I was there with my american friends just having a good time, but after 5

Most Recent Blogs

African victims of racism in India share their stories

The law of mobs is always there,’ says one student, describing racist attacks on Africans

AI ROBOTS LEARNING RACISM, SEXISM AND OTHER PREJUDICES FROM HUMANS, STUDY FINDS

‘These technologies may perpetuate cultural stereotypes’ IAN JOHNSTON SCIENCE CORRESPONDENT THE INDEPENDENT TECH Artificially intelligent

70,000 Indian Muslim clerics issue fatwa against terrorism

70,000 Indian Muslim clerics issue fatwa against Isis, the Taliban, al-Qaeda and other terror groups

Social Media Star Strangled In ‘Honor’ Killing

“This beautiful woman spent her last moments alive knowing her own brother was strangling her.

Support the Movement

With your little support we can take the movement forward to fight against racism in the World.

Featured Videos

First Lady Michelle Obama on the issue of Race in America

Top 5 Racist Countries

Total Racist Reports: 1177

  • United States 758 (100%)
  • United Kingdom 105 (14%)
  • Australia 29 (4%)
  • South Africa 26 (3%)
  • Canada 25 (3%)